Skip to Main Content

Critically evaluating journal papers

The ABCs of critical thinking!

Authority

  • Who is providing the information? 
    • The Authors / Publishers:
      • Are they ‘qualified’ to write about the subject area?
      • What are their credentials? organisational affiliations? e-mail addresses?
      • Has the paper been reviewed or refereed?
      • Does it include a bibliography?
      • How reputable is the publisher?

Check your paper!

  • Is there an author listed?
  • Is there information about the author’s credentials or experience?
  • Does the author reference all sources?
  • Is the article scholarly?
  • Has the article been reviewed or refereed?

The Library, Technological University of the Shannon: Midwest